Used Tesla Model S for Sale in New York City Metro

Local market overview

There are currently 26 used Tesla Model S listings for sale in the New York City Metro area on OwneDeals, aggregated from Tesla Certified Pre-Owned inventory, partner dealers, and private sellers. The median local asking price is $26,745, with most listings between $16,248 and $49,825, and the average odometer reading is 89,505 miles.

Over the last 30 days, 29 used Tesla Model Ss sold in the New York City Metro market at a median sold price of $58,600, spending about 30 days listed before selling.

Market analysis — used Tesla Model S in New York City Metro

New York City Metro Model S listings skew older than the recent sold market.

Active inventory

24 listings

Median ask

$21,368

30-day median sold

$58,600

Avg listing miles

90,827 miles

In the New York City Metro, the live Model S market looks different from the cars that actually changed hands recently. Current inventory consists of 24 listings with a $21,368 median ask, 90,827 average miles, and 34 average days listed, while 29 cars sold in the last 30 days at a $58,600 median. By year, the market splits between older cars at $14,999 to $18,622 in 2016 and 2017 and much newer cars at $53,794 to $65,300 in 2022 and 2023. If you are comparing local listings, treat model year and mileage as the main filters first, then narrow by trim since All-Wheel Drive is the deepest part of the market.

• Active and sold mixes look very different: The New York City Metro has 24 active Model S listings, and 29 sold over the last 30 days. Active cars carry a $21,368 median ask and spend 34 days listed on average, while the recent sold median is $58,600.
• The local ask band is wide: The middle half of current asks runs from $15,896 to $49,150, and active inventory averages 90,827 miles. That spread is a reminder to compare mileage and model year closely before using any single price point as a reference.
• Older and newer years sit in separate tiers: Among visible year buckets, 2017 listings have a $14,999 median ask and 2016 listings are at $18,622, while 2022 rises to $53,794 and 2023 reaches $65,300. These medians come from 5, 4, 5, and 3 listings respectively, so local year-to-year gaps can reflect mix as well as age.
• 2023 asks and sold prices line up: For 2023 Model S in the New York City Metro, the median ask and median sold price are both $65,300. The recorded ask-versus-sold delta for that year is $0.
• AWD is the largest local trim pool: Model S All-Wheel Drive accounts for 9 active listings in the New York City Metro. Plaid is next at 4, and several other trims are clustered at 2 to 4 listings each.

Bottom line: In New York City Metro, current Model S asks center at $21,368, while recent sales center at $58,600 and active inventory averages 90,827 miles.

AI-generated summary of the data shown on this page, last updated 2026-09-21. Figures are directional, not an appraisal.

Median asking price — New York City Metro (last 30 days)

Price by model year — New York City Metro

Price vs. mileage — New York City Metro

What’s available — Model S trims in New York City Metro

Shop all used Tesla Model S listings in New York City Metro

Browse every used Tesla Model S for sale in New York City Metro on OwneDeals → Filter by price, mileage, range, Autopilot hardware (HW3 / HW4), and trim.

About this data

Methodology: figures cover the New York City Metro metro (a curated group of local cities). Active-listing statistics reflect vehicles marked for sale when this page was generated. Recently-sold figures use each listing’s last-updated timestamp as a sold-date proxy and are directional market signal, not an appraisal. Trend data comes from OwneDeals’ own inventory snapshots.

Research by DK · OwneDeals Research.