Used Tesla Model Y for Sale in New York City Metro
173 local listings · median $31,561 · 331 sold in 30 days
Local market overview
There are currently 173 used Tesla Model Y listings for sale in the New York City Metro area on OwneDeals, aggregated from Tesla Certified Pre-Owned inventory, partner dealers, and private sellers. The median local asking price is $31,561, with most listings between $25,990 and $38,000, and the average odometer reading is 66,747 miles.
Over the last 30 days, 331 used Tesla Model Ys sold in the New York City Metro market at a median sold price of $35,100, spending about 19 days listed before selling.
Market analysis — used Tesla Model Y in New York City Metro
New York City Metro Model Y asks trail recent sold prices.
- Active listings
- 143 listings
- Recent sold count
- 328 sold
- Median ask
- $29,840
- Median sold
- $34,900
In the New York City Metro, Model Y shoppers are looking at 143 active listings against 328 recent sold vehicles, and the medians are not aligned: $29,840 asked versus $34,900 sold. By year, sold medians step from $25,196 for 2020 to $46,294 for 2026, and the ask-to-sold relationship changes with them, including a $1,275 ask premium in 2020 but a -$6,303 gap in 2021. Most supply is concentrated in 102 Long Range All-Wheel Drive listings, so that trim will shape many of the local price comparisons you make. With active listings averaging 71,432 miles, the most useful local comparison is not just ask versus sold, but year, trim, and mileage together.
- Recent sales are higher than current asks: In the New York City Metro, the recent median sold price for a Model Y is $34,900, while the current median ask is $29,840. Current asking prices run from $24,858 to $35,500 in the middle of the market, placing the sold median near the top of that band.
- Model-year pricing has a clear local ladder: By model year in the New York City Metro, median sold prices run from $25,196 for 2020 to $29,050 for 2021, $29,900 for 2022, $35,150 for 2023, $38,600 for 2024, and $46,294 for 2026. Use that sequence to decide whether moving up a model year changes the local target price enough to matter for your search.
- Ask-to-sold gaps vary sharply by year: The local gap flips depending on model year. In 2020, median ask is $26,471 versus median sold at $25,196, a $1,275 ask premium; in 2021, median ask is $22,747 versus median sold at $29,050, a -$6,303 gap. The sold-above-ask pattern continues in 2022 at -$3,270, 2023 at -$1,763, 2024 at -$2,003, and 2026 at -$2,000.
- Mileage should be your local price baseline: Active Model Y listings in the New York City Metro average 71,432 miles. When a listing is priced near the median ask of $29,840, compare its odometer first: being above or below 71,432 miles is one of the first things to check against the recent sold median of $34,900.
- Most local supply is Long Range AWD: Of 143 active Model Y listings in the New York City Metro, 102 are Long Range All-Wheel Drive and 29 are Performance All-Wheel Drive. The rest of the market is 8 Rear-Wheel Drive, 3 All-Wheel Drive, and 1 Other, so most local comparisons will be against Long Range inventory.
Bottom line: In the New York City Metro, the median ask is $29,840 versus a $34,900 median sold, so compare year and 71,432 miles alongside list price.
AI-generated summary of the data shown on this page, last updated 2026-10-12. Figures are directional, not an appraisal.
Median asking price — New York City Metro (last 30 days)
| Week | Median asking price |
|---|---|
| Sep 14 | $31,800 |
| Sep 21 | $31,300 |
| Sep 28 | $31,480 |
| Oct 05 | $30,500 |
| Oct 12 | $32,460 |
Price by model year — New York City Metro
| Model year | Median asking | Active listings | Median sold |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | $25,748 | 5 | $25,196 |
| 2021 | $22,497 | 33 | $29,900 |
| 2022 | $27,944 | 36 | $29,747 |
| 2023 | $36,894 | 78 | $35,300 |
| 2024 | $37,440 | 12 | $38,600 |
| 2026 | $46,997 | 7 | $46,600 |
Price vs. mileage — New York City Metro
What’s available — Model Y trims in New York City Metro
| Trim | Active listings |
|---|---|
| Long Range All-Wheel Drive | 128 |
| Performance All-Wheel Drive | 32 |
| Model Y Rear-Wheel Drive | 6 |
| Model Y All-Wheel Drive | 4 |
| Other | 1 |
| Long Range Rear-Wheel Drive | 1 |
| Standard Range Rear-Wheel Drive | 1 |
Shop all used Tesla Model Y listings in New York City Metro
Browse every used Tesla Model Y for sale in New York City Metro on OwneDeals → Filter by price, mileage, range, Autopilot hardware (HW3 / HW4), and trim.
About this data
Methodology: figures cover the New York City Metro metro (a curated group of local cities). Active-listing statistics reflect vehicles marked for sale when this page was generated. Recently-sold figures use each listing’s last-updated timestamp as a sold-date proxy and are directional market signal, not an appraisal. Trend data comes from OwneDeals’ own inventory snapshots.
Research by DK · OwneDeals Research.