Used Tesla Model Y for Sale in New York City Metro
177 local listings · median $32,800 · 346 sold in 30 days
Local market overview
There are currently 177 used Tesla Model Y listings for sale in the New York City Metro area on OwneDeals, aggregated from Tesla Certified Pre-Owned inventory, partner dealers, and private sellers. The median local asking price is $32,800, with most listings between $25,990 and $35,871, and the average odometer reading is 59,600 miles.
Over the last 30 days, 346 used Tesla Model Ys sold in the New York City Metro market at a median sold price of $34,600, spending about 16 days listed before selling.
Market analysis — used Tesla Model Y in New York City Metro
New York City Metro Model Y asks sit below recent sales, with 2023 inventory setting the market center.
- Median ask
- $33,350
- Median sold
- $34,600
- Active inventory
- 204 listings
- Avg listed miles
- 54,258 miles
New York City Metro's used Model Y market is active, with 275 sold in the last 30 days against 204 active listings and an average listing age of 14 days. Current inventory is centered slightly below recent transactions, with a $33,350 median ask versus a $34,600 median sold price. 2023 is the easiest year to benchmark because it has 96 active listings and a tight $35,050 ask versus $34,400 sold, while 2021, 2022, and 2020 each show sold medians above their ask medians. Most local supply is Long Range All-Wheel Drive at 150 listings, and the average odometer reads 54,258 miles, so shoppers should keep both trim and mileage aligned when comparing prices.
- Recent sales run above live asks: In New York City Metro, the median active ask is $33,350, while the median sold price over the last 30 days is $34,600. The market also logged 275 sales versus 204 active listings, and the average listing age is 14 days.
- 2023 is the clearest local benchmark: 2023 accounts for 96 active listings in New York City Metro, compared with 26 for 2022 and 25 for 2024. Its median ask is $35,050 and its median sold price is $34,400, with an ask-vs-sold delta of $650.
- Older years often sell above their current asks: For 2021, the median ask is $23,997 and the median sold price is $28,900. The same pattern shows up in 2022 at $28,644 ask and $31,500 sold, and in 2020 at $24,997 ask and $26,798 sold.
- Newer model years step up sharply: Median sold price reaches $39,600 for 2024, $40,995 for 2025, and $45,750 for 2026 in the New York City Metro. Those newer-year medians come from 25 listings for 2024, 4 for 2025, and 7 for 2026, so the newer end of the market is thinner than 2023.
- Use mileage as a local comparison filter: The average active Model Y in New York City Metro shows 54,258 miles, and the middle of the asking market runs from $27,888 to $36,296 around a $33,350 median. When local listings are close in year and trim, comparing them against that 54,258-mile benchmark makes the price context clearer.
Bottom line: In New York City Metro, 2023 Model Y listings near $35,050 are the clearest benchmark, with 54,258 miles as the local mileage baseline.
AI-generated summary of the data shown on this page, last updated 2026-08-24. Figures are directional, not an appraisal.
Median asking price — New York City Metro (last 30 days)
| Week | Median asking price |
|---|---|
| Jul 27 | $34,300 |
| Aug 03 | $34,100 |
| Aug 10 | $33,800 |
| Aug 17 | $34,100 |
| Aug 24 | $33,700 |
| Aug 31 | $35,800 |
Price by model year — New York City Metro
| Model year | Median asking | Active listings | Median sold |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | $22,997 | 9 | $27,150 |
| 2021 | $22,997 | 33 | $29,050 |
| 2022 | $29,894 | 33 | $31,300 |
| 2023 | $34,150 | 70 | $34,550 |
| 2024 | $36,200 | 19 | $39,400 |
| 2025 | $35,890 | 7 | $40,990 |
| 2026 | $45,986 | 6 | $46,700 |
Price vs. mileage — New York City Metro
What’s available — Model Y trims in New York City Metro
| Trim | Active listings |
|---|---|
| Long Range All-Wheel Drive | 122 |
| Performance All-Wheel Drive | 35 |
| Model Y All-Wheel Drive | 8 |
| Model Y Rear-Wheel Drive | 7 |
| Premium All-Wheel Drive | 3 |
| Long Range Rear-Wheel Drive | 2 |
Shop all used Tesla Model Y listings in New York City Metro
Browse every used Tesla Model Y for sale in New York City Metro on OwneDeals → Filter by price, mileage, range, Autopilot hardware (HW3 / HW4), and trim.
About this data
Methodology: figures cover the New York City Metro metro (a curated group of local cities). Active-listing statistics reflect vehicles marked for sale when this page was generated. Recently-sold figures use each listing’s last-updated timestamp as a sold-date proxy and are directional market signal, not an appraisal. Trend data comes from OwneDeals’ own inventory snapshots.
Research by DK · OwneDeals Research.